Convenience,
Savings And a Sense of
Security | It
seems not a day goes by that you don’t hear something about
airport security. Among the more newsworthy developments in
recent weeks:
-
Alternative Access to Business
Aircraft |
There are many ways to gain
the use of a business jet, determined by regulatory
considerations, costs, tax consequences, security
concerns and simple preferences. Here is a list of
some of the alternatives to fractional
ownership: Owner-Operator
– Your company buys its own
aircraft, either new or used and is responsible for
hiring crew and maintenance workers, as well as
arranging for other support services. You can help
defray costs by putting the aircraft into service
under separate arrangements with charter operators
when your company is not using the
plane. Joint Ownership
– The aircraft is registered
under multiple owner names and the acquisition and
ownership costs are
shared. Time Sharing
– Your business leases an
aircraft and crew from another owner. The charges are
generally limited to slightly more than direct
operating costs for the flights.
Aircraft
Interchange – Your company owns a
plane and can lease another owner’s aircraft with crew
in exchange for equal-value time on your company’s
aircraft. Operating Lease
– The owner of the aircraft
divests full control and responsibility for the plane
to your company. Your business is then responsible for
crew, insurance and the full cost and risk of
maintaining and operating the aircraft. The lease
amount generally covers financing costs and a profit
for the owner. You may also be charged a monthly
reserve for maintenance. The owner retains
depreciation tax benefits and an interest in the
residual value at the end of the lease. Leases may be
structured as
lease-purchases.
Sale Leaseback
– This involves the simultaneous
sale of an aircraft to a financing company, and then
leasing it from the company. The owner retains tax
benefits. Charter
– Your business hires an aircraft
and crew for a specific flight. The aircraft operator
has full regulatory burden. Before
signing on to any of these arrangements, check with
your company's advisers about financial, legal,
regulatory and tax implications. |
| The United
States and Canada agreed to loosen the ban on liquids
and gels in carry-on luggage.
- Israeli airport security experts visit LAX to offer
suggestions on how to protect travelers and prevent
terrorist attacks.
- Thirty-three airports are installing scanners to read
e-passports from 27 ally nations whose citizens don't need
visas to visit the U.S.
It’s a fact of life. Officials, legislators and travelers
around the globe have had security on their minds since the
September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. As a result, airport
security has increased and travel has been restricted. In the
meantime, business and leisure travelers must deal with the
consequences.
This has led many companies to consider
the pros and cons of fractional jet ownership. Having access
to a corporate jet not only helps employees feel more secure
and relaxed when flying, it can also slash traveling time and
costs. For example, the time to fly from New York to Toronto,
office door to office door, usually takes four or more hours
by commercial airliner, including airport check in and waiting
time. By corporate jet, the time can drop to just
two-and-a-half hours.
How It
Works
In a fractional ownership
arrangement, a company buys (or in some cases leases) a share
in an aircraft. The company can then use that aircraft for a
certain number of hours or days a year. If that plane is
unavailable when it is needed, the company generally gains
access to a pool of identical or similar aircraft.
When
weighing whether to buy, charter, or fractionally own an
aircraft, the general rule of thumb is:
Charter a jet if your
company’s flying requirements range from zero to 100 hours a
year.
Buy a fractional
ownership if flying time averages from 101
hours to 399 hours a year.
Operate your
own fleet if flying time is 400 hours a year
or more.
While there are many savings to be realized by buying
fractional interests in a business jet, the programs are still
pricey. There are four costs involved, three of them fixed and
one variable:
1. Initial
outlay for the ownership share. 2. A
monthly management fee for crew, training, hangar, and
insurance. 3. A
base hourly rate for each hour flown that includes
maintenance, standard catering, and normal landing
fees. 4. A
variable fuel adjustment component that is added to the base
hourly rate to account for fuel price
fluctuations.
As an example, one U.S. fractional ownership
company charges more than $800,000 for a 1/8th ownership
in a Raytheon Hawker 400 XP, which includes 100 hours of
flying time. In addition, it charges a monthly management fee
of more than $11,000 and an hourly direct operating charge of
more than $1,600, excluding the variable fuel surcharge,
international fees and a federal excise tax of 7.5 percent.
That company writes initial ownership agreements for five
years, so you create a bank of hours that your company will
use over that time.
Tax
Consequences
The tax implications of owning aircraft or a
fractional interest are extremely complex.
Do not rely on
statements made by sales representatives. This is a time when
you need expert tax advice before purchasing.
As
a Tax attorney, I will investigate the relevant sales and use
taxes charged by different states. Tax deductions depend on a
variety of factors including ownership, depreciation,
maintenance and insurance costs.
The American
Jobs Creation Act of 2004 and IRS Notice 2005-45
made significant changes involving the personal use tax
treatment of a company plane. Before you sign anything or make any commitments
to purchase call
me!
The
Advantages
Among the benefits of
fractional ownership of a business aircraft:
Having an aircraft, crew, scheduling, and maintenance on
demand.
Access to thousands more airports than commercial
airliners, many of them significantly closer to your
ultimate destination.
Savings that statistically include four hours of travel
time and eight hours productive time for each trip (you can
hold meetings during flight time), fewer hotel bills and
overnight time, and $1,400 in direct costs, airfare, salary,
and expenses.
Guaranteed costs over the term of the arrangement, with
the exception of the variable fuel charges.
Less time away from the office and more time with
families. The
Complications
However, fractional
ownership is a complicated transaction that you shouldn’t just
rush into. Talk to an aviation specialist who can perform due
diligence on the company you plan to buy from and help you
understand what is involved when you sign the many documents
required.
It's also a good idea to develop a
travel profile that includes answers to the following
questions: Who in your company will be using the plane and for
what purposes? What is the estimated average trip length? How
much baggage will be carried?
Because fractional
ownership programs are complicated, here is a list of some
more questions to answer before going forward:
|
Pre-Purchase
Checklist |
|
Costs |
|
How small an interest
can your business buy? Check for economies of scale —
your company could gain an advantage by buying two
1/16th interests in two different planes rather than a
single 1/8th interest in one plane. |
|
What will ownership
cost your business every year? |
|
Can you lease rather
than buy? |
|
Are there any hidden
costs? |
|
What is the company’s
cancellation or buyback policy? |
|
Can you negotiate
better terms with the company or with another company
that offers fractional ownership? |
|
How does the company
calculate your hours of usage? Some companies, for
example, calculate it as the time between wheels up and
wheels down plus 12 minutes (six minutes prior to
takeoff and six minutes after landing.) |
|
Liability |
|
What is your company’s
responsibility if the plane is damaged while you are
using it? What if it is damaged while another fractional
owner is using it? |
|
What liability does
your business have if the aircraft is operated
negligently by one of the other owners? |
|
Will your business
have any licensing obligations to U.S. or other
regulators? |
|
What happens if other
fractional owners don't pay their share? |
|
Safety |
|
How is the plane
maintained and kept up to safety standards? |
|
Who supplies the
maintenance? |
|
What can you put into
the agreement to ensure the safety of the
jet? |
|
What is the safety
record of the people involved? |
|
General |
|
What is the range of
the aircraft? |
|
Can you use the plane
anywhere in the U.S., Canada, Mexico or
Europe? |
|
Where can you
not fly the plane? (war zones, no-fly zones or
areas that have travel warnings to U.S.
citizens?) |
|
Can you and other
employees take a test flight? |
|
Can a qualified pilot
from your company fly the plane? |
|
What happens if
someone else is using the plane? |
|
Can you sell, exchange
or transfer your fractional interest to another party
without the consent of the lessor? |
|
What happens if there
are no more planes like yours in the pool of available
jets? |
| | |
|